Kate: It's time for the judges' verdict. Sharon?
Sharon: I love the simplicity of the song. It was all about their voices, all about their souls. I mean you just nailed it, you really, really nailed it! (big cheers) ... And... might I add, you looked stunning! All three of you! (Big smiles from the girls) Fabulous! The three divas!
Kate: Thank you Sharon. Simon?
Simon: Errr... (tentatively) good... I think that this won't sound as good on television as it did sound in here. I think some of the tuning was out. I think you needed more preparation for the song. I thought the choice of song was spot on! But er, this is one of those records on which it will expose you when you're out of tune and I think there were tuning problems on that performance, I really do. (muted boos)
Kate: Were there Louis?
Louis: No-oo. He's obviously got different ears...
Simon: No good asking Louis because he's deaf! (laughter)
Louis: Helloo! You're the one who's made all the bad records, Simon. These girls were fantastic and look at them! (cheers) What a transformation!
Simon: But you don't think they were out of tune?
Louis: Sorry, what was that? (puts his hand up to his ear)
Simon: You... you didn't think they were out of tune? ...You didn't think they were out of tune?
Louis: Absolutely not! And nobody here did. (sounds of support from the audience, Simon smiles. Sharon raises her hand for permission to speak.)
Kate: Sharon?
Sharon: I just think there were a couple of points where you were, but we're not making a record, we're making t.v.
Louis: And it's live.
Sharon: So it doesn't matter!
Louis: And it's real.(applause)
Kate: (to Voices With Soul) Ladies! Some criticism there from Simon. Do you feel that you came out tonight and didn't manage to hit all those notes?
There's a bit of a silence. The girls seem a little shocked and dumbstruck. Hildia pipes up as spokeperson
Hildia: Well... we have to listen back to it really, and see.
Kate: How are you feeling?
Hildia: Feeling good!
Louis: They're really nervous... (drowned out by support from the audience)
Kate: (to the girls) Do you feel that you delivered tonight? Are you pleased with your performance?
Hildia: Yeah, we've done our best, so...(the girls all nod)
Kate: Well listen, you're live to the nation. Why should the public pick up the phone for you girls tonight?
Grace: We've been singing together for a long time in our local churches, and we thank X Factor for giving us this chance to be able to show the people what we can do! (cheers)
Kate: Thank you very much.
Hildia: We are...(cheers) ... This is a dream come true for us and we're living this dream as a family, with my sister Grace, and my niece Corene.
Kate: Okay, well girls, let's see where that goes tonight. For now it's Louis and Voices With Soul!